Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Poor Yorick Collect the skull from Joe. | 99.56% | |
 | Scaredy Cat Complete Story Mode with no Black Cat scares. | 72.45% | |
 | Master Locksmith Complete the Captain's lock puzzle. | 69.38% | |
 | Mark Twain Award Complete the bonus chapter. | 60.88% | |
 | Devil's Advocate Complete Story Mode. | 53.89% | |
 | Beady Eyes Unlock Unlimited Hidden Object Mode. | 50.13% | |
 | Golden Geek Solve all the puzzles in Story Mode. | 41.46% | |
 | Hustler Clear the pool table in one shot. | 32.31% | |
 | Black Hole Complete each HOG in Story Mode without the lantern. | 27.02% | |
 | Perfect Complete Story Mode without using any hints. | 25.01% | |
 | Bone Dry Find all of them 80 bones in "Dem Bones." | 23.01% | |
 | Devil's in the Details Find every hidden object in all Unlimited HO Mode scenes. | 14.66% | |
 | HOG Wild Complete a hidden object scene in less than a minute in Story mode. | 13.42% | |
 | Dead Eye Find all the boats in Deptford without a miss. | 11.14% | |
 | Ornithologist Collect all the ravens in Story Mode. | 9.89% | |
 | Irish Rover Collect 100 clovers in Story Mode. | 8.96% |