Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | So Much Death Completed the prologue | 99.76% | |
 | Compassionate Soul Compassionate was one of top two traits for Andrew | 64.04% | |
| On A Roll Completed 5 combat events in succession | 61.81% | |
| Amiable Character Amiable was one of top two traits for Daniel | 56.64% | |
| Solid As a Rock Maximized Daniel and Taylor's Relationship | 52.52% | |
| Strength From Within Saved Andrew | 51.23% | |
| Deeper Understanding Understanding was one of top two traits for Angela | 48.41% | |
| Forgiveness Saved Mary | 43.24% | |
| Headstrong Heroine Headstrong was one of top two traits for Taylor | 43.01% | |
| Unbroken Saved Daniel | 41.01% | |
| We Are of Water Saved Angela | 35.84% | |
| Heavy Burden Saved John | 35.02% | |
| Full Circle Completed the Solo Story | 24.68% | |
| Free Spirit Saved Taylor | 19.39% | |
| Our Own Demons Defeated Taylor's demons | 19.27% | |
| All Together Now Andrew has a good relationship with all characters | 14.1% | |
| Deathly Visions Found all of the black framed Pictures | 13.75% | |
| Rational Mind Rational was one of top two traits for John | 11.16% | |
| Fate Worse Than Death Andrew was saved from himself | 9.75% | |
| Salvation Everyone was saved | 7.64% | |
| Coven of Witches Finished Movie Night | 7.64% | |
| The Odd Couple Maximized Angela and John's Relationship | 6.58% | |
| Glimmer of Hope Found all of the white framed Pictures | 2.47% | |
| A Complete Picture Found all Pictures | 2.35% | |
| That Dream is Your Enemy No-one survived | 1.76% | |
| Dirty Little Secrets Found all witchcraft secrets | 1.41% | |
| Secrets Too Dark Found all family secrets | 1.41% | |
| Instinctive Reaction Chose all of the Heart decisions | 1.06% | |
| Considered Opinion Chose all of the Head decisions | 1.06% | |
| No Escaping Fate Everyone died at the ruined house | 0.94% |