Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Abel Complete the final chapter with Cain | 93.7% | |
 | Blood Lust Kill moms heart with Samson | 93.6% | |
 | Blood Rights Kill Satan with Samson | 93.29% | |
 | The Candle Complete Challenge 1 | 93.26% | |
 | Guppys Tail Complete Challenge 4 | 92.97% | |
 | Samson Kill mom but pass on 2 treasure room items | 92.97% | |
 | Mega Fetus Complete Challenge 6 | 92.94% | |
 | The Lucky Toe Complete Challenge 2 | 92.91% | |
 | Daddys love ??? | 92.87% | |
 | The Spider Butt Complete Challenge 8 | 92.81% | |
 | The Burnt Penny Complete Challenge 3 | 92.81% | |
 | Super SMB Fan Complete Challenge 7 | 92.77% | |
 | The D20 Complete the final chapter with Isaac | 92.69% | |
 | Guppys Hairball ??? | 92.68% | |
 | Dads Key ??? | 92.64% | |
 | The Polaroid ??? | 92.64% | |
 | The Fish Head Complete Challenge 5 | 92.6% | |
 | The Sacrificial Knife Complete the final chapter with Eve | 92.57% | |
 | The Bloody Penny Complete the final chapter with Samson | 92.52% | |
 | The Rainbow Baby Complete the final chapter with ??? | 92.51% | |
 | The Cross Complete the final chapter with Maggy | 92.48% | |
 | The Curved Horn Complete the final chapter with Judas | 92.47% | |
 | The Counterfeit Coin Complete Challenge 9 | 92.45% | |
 | Platinum God! 100% the game | 92.42% |