Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | The Shark Is Now Psychic Beat New Game+ with ever possible party member in your roster, and all wearing Shark Week outfits. [SHARK WEEK DLC] | 100% | |
 | Legendary Rat Pixies Completed "God Makes Gnome Mistakes". [DLC] | 100% | |
 | YOUR PYLONS ARE CURRENTLY UNDER AN UNREASONABLE AMOUNT OF STRESS Completed "World of Bardcraft" | 100% | |
 | Reconstruction Era Rebuilt Innsmouth and united the warring factions. | 100% | |
| Noah's ARK Freed the ARK Creatures from a lifetime of slavery. | 100% | |
 | So We're Doing This Challenge Alexander Hamilton to a duel to the death. | 100% | 19/02/2019, 15:57:34 |
| War of the Elven King Completed "War of the Elven King" | 100% | |
 | Enid Free Canadian Dave first. | 100% | |
 | Twelve Stories High, Made of Radiation Sign the Declaration of Independence. | 100% | |
 | Terror from the Deep Rebuilt Devil Reef and united the warring factions. | 100% | |
 | Beer Quest Completed "Elizabeth Reign" | 100% | |
 | Breakfast Club of the Damned | 100% | 28/02/2019, 00:34:30 |
 | Stars are Right ENDING 1. R'yleh rose, and destroyed everything in its bloody wake. | 100% | |
| I Hear The Jury's Still Out On Science Open up a sacred land to the public. | 100% | |
 | God of Balance: KNOCKED OFF Completed "Jack Dodger and the Tomb of Keziah Mason" | 100% | |
 | It Launches Vampire Kangaroos Equip the Vampire Kangaroo Launcher. | 100% | |
| Least Favorite X-Files Episode (After Space) | 100% | |
 | The Model of a Modern Major General Equip yourself with the Geek King Encyclopedia, Vampire Kangaroo Launcher, New England Charm, Snow Shoes, and Ancient Irish Cap. | 100% | |
| Is It Like Dark Souls 2? | 100% | |
 | "Oh my god, it's a SUMMER.... sale." Equip the Shotgun from Doom. | 100% | |
 | God of Chaos: ORDERED Completed "Illegal Aliens" | 100% | 28/02/2019, 00:43:37 |
| The Apocalypse Can Wait Do every side quest. | 100% | |
 | End of the World Beat New Game+. | 100% | |
| The Search for More Money | 100% | |
| The Bad Ending ENDING 2. So, this is awkward. | 100% | |
| Lobby Full | 100% | |
 | Monster Mash Completed "The Return of Lil' Sebastian" | 100% | |
 | Fake Geek Girl As a girl, fight Ignus Ross in San Diego. | 100% | |
 | God of Animals: EXTINCT Completed "The Godmeet" | 100% | |
 | Obsidian Could'a Done The Sequel Decide the fate of a shadow government. | 100% | |
| You Can See It From Here ENDING 4. The world once more belongs to the humans. | 100% | |
| Devilfish | 100% | |
 | Watch Dawgs Helped the Deep Ones find a new home in San Francisco. | 100% | 28/02/2019, 00:42:25 |
 | God of Conflict: RESOLVED IN GROUP THERAPY Completed "The Future" | 100% | |
 | You were in for a bad time, man. Welp. That happened. | 100% | |
 | Marvel's Passive Fist Talk your way out of five fights. | 100% | |
 | God of Cycles: RECYCLED Completed "Some Assembly Required" | 100% | |
 | Gods of Science: BORN AGAIN Completed "Evolutionary War" | 100% | |
| The San Francisco Look ENDING 3. The Deep Ones carried on with the legacy of Dagon, furthering the Old God agenda and taking over Cthulhu's turf whilst he slept. | 100% | |
 | Wordsmith Mark Twain One shot an enemy. | 100% | |
| Cabinet Battle #4 | 100% | |
| Bifrost Protected a sacred land. | 100% | |
| Stars are Right 2: Human Revolution | 100% | |
 | Comin' To Save The Day, Yeah! Free American Dave first. | 100% | 19/02/2019, 15:37:19 |
 | ACHIEVEMENTS ARE SPOILERS! Spoil the future season of a beloved show to the entirety of Ballroom 20. | 100% | |
 | There's Only 'I' in Team Don't do any Loyalty Missions. | 100% | |
| "Here's some money, buy some exclusives for me." Beat New Game+ with a every possible party member in your roster, and all wearing San Diego Comic-Con outfits. [SDCC EXCLUSIVES 2017 DLC] | 100% | |
 | Robert Pattinson Romance Nodens. [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 66.67% | |
| Squidlover Romance Cthylla. [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 66.67% | |
| Last of the Cat Girls Completed "Isle of the Cat Girls". [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 66.67% | |
 | Murder in the Worst Degree | 66.67% | |
| It's About Time Wars Romance Ansel West. [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 66.67% | |
| Snake Charmer Romance Yig. [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 66.67% | |
 | The Nightmare Before Steam Winter Sale Save Christmas. [DLC] | 66.67% | 24/02/2019, 21:39:01 |
| Romance Optimus Prime Romance Hamlet Prime. [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 66.67% | |
| INSANE LOW PRICES!!!!! Completed "Black Friday Blitz". [DLC] | 66.67% | |
 | Dork Universe Completed "Call of Koithulhu". [DLC] | 66.67% | |
| Like An Elephant Romance Chaugnar Faugn. [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 66.67% | |
| Leslie Nope Romance Dagon. [ISLE OF THE CAT GIRLS DLC] | 33.33% |