Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Survive the Internet: Second-Degree Burn Get the Best Burn twice in one game | 70.58% | |
 | Civic Doodle: Reelection Get both of your additions accepted in a single round (non final round) | 65.45% | 27/10/2021, 08:54:18 |
 | Civic Doodle: Popular Vote Get all player votes and 90% of audience votes in a single matchup (5+ player game) | 47.44% | |
 | Monster Seeking Monster: Consolation Prize Nobody gets a date during one of the nights | 38.37% | 04/11/2021, 02:25:43 |
 | Civic Doodle: Civic Doodie Draw something that gets 100 poop emojis | 34.41% | 05/11/2021, 03:50:43 |
| Survive the Internet: Stick Pic Select the image of the animal that lives the "life of a twig eater" | 24.6% | |
 | Fibbage 3: Crowd Teaser Audience fools a player | 23.14% | |
 | Survive the Internet: Yasss Gene Beat Gene in a game | 20.65% | |
 | Monster Seeking Monster: MasterDater A player successfully gets a date all six nights of the game | 19.77% | |
| Civic Doodle: Design by Committee Each part of the final round portrait comes from a different player | 18.16% | 05/11/2021, 03:47:07 |
 | Bracketeering: Clean Sweep Win a bracket with an answer that gets 100% of the votes each round | 16.25% | |
| Survive the Internet: Shadow Star Win a game without getting a Best Burn | 14.06% | |
 | Fibbage 3: Open Book All players pick the truth in a 5+ player game of Enough About You (non final round) | 13.62% | |
| Bracketeering: Cinderella Story Win a bracket with an answer that everyone predicted would lose each round | 12.45% | |
| Bracketeering: Split Decision Have a match up go to overtime with an audience playing along | 8.79% | |
| Fibbage 3: Doubly Impressive Write a lie that's actually the truth in the final round of Fibbage 3 | 8.35% | |
| Fibbage 3: Would You Believe? Fool 7 players in the final round of Enough About You | 3.66% | |
| Monster Seeking Monster: I'm Lycan It Finish a game with everyone turned into werewolves | 2.34% | |
| Monster Seeking Monster: Mob Rule Finish a game with the Audience as the winner | 1.32% | |
| Bracketeering: Button Masher Win a 4-way tied overtime match up | 0.29% |