Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Feed Fill Petronius' bowl. | 94% | 02/03/2024, 06:42:36 |
 | Melody Listen to Faye's song all the way through. | 92.96% | 02/03/2024, 07:09:50 |
 | One Complete Ed's first therapy session. | 87.17% | 02/03/2024, 07:34:18 |
 | Hand Get Ed to shake Julia's hand. | 85.98% | 02/03/2024, 06:11:03 |
 | Blanket Do not let Faye get cold. | 83.46% | 02/03/2024, 06:49:55 |
 | Sam Find Samuel Franklin. | 78.7% | 02/03/2024, 09:09:40 |
 | Two Complete Ed's second therapy session. | 71.43% | 02/03/2024, 11:10:59 |
 | Support Comfort Robert. | 70.09% | 02/03/2024, 11:31:42 |
 | Gun Find evidence against Ed Miller. | 68.9% | 02/03/2024, 11:43:16 |
 | Three Complete Ed's third therapy session. | 67.72% | 02/03/2024, 12:01:35 |
 | Groceries Get mom's congratulations for storing the groceries quickly. | 67.72% | 02/03/2024, 10:25:16 |
 | Four Complete Ed's fourth therapy session. | 65.04% | 02/03/2024, 13:28:53 |
 | Tree Dive into Julia and Nick's past. | 64.75% | 02/03/2024, 13:34:19 |
 | Five Complete Ed's fifth therapy session. | 62.22% | |
| Engine Fix a car. | 62.07% | |
| Jenny Confirm the existence of Ed's daughter. | 61.48% | |
| Canyon Throw Ed's car down the cliff. | 61.18% | |
| BFF Kill Lisa Horowitz. | 60.59% | |
| Host Make sure Ed doesn't get thirsty. | 60.44% | |
| Orphan Get rid of your father's influence. | 59.85% | |
| Scar Take a seat. | 59.4% | |
| Pliers Convince Adam to release you. | 59.25% | |
| Vertigo Overcome Vertigo by saving Esther Franklin and Jenny. | 59.1% | |
| Restaurant Dine at Mamma Louise. | 58.06% | |
| Flamingo Say goodbye to a childhood friend. | 57.32% | |
| Romance Get Julia and Nick together. | 55.84% | |
 | Brotherhood Complete the Pirate Brotherhood's secret handshake. | 41.13% | 02/03/2024, 10:09:15 |
 | Feast Feed Frankie Laine just like he deserves. | 39.06% | 02/03/2024, 08:35:49 |
 | Stone Access one of Julia's childhood memories. | 36.09% | 02/03/2024, 07:41:53 |
 | MVP Help Eddie Miller become the season's hero. | 32.52% | 02/03/2024, 09:25:33 |
 | Figurines Find all of Captain Roberts' spies. | 22.42% | 02/03/2024, 09:40:27 |